The New Yorker
“Quietly transfixing…In the atmospheric catacombs below Green-Wood Cemetery, the singers of Cathedra, supported by the string ensemble Abendmusik, enact an immersive ritual around a candlelit table, raising their voices, one to a part, in Byrd’s solemn strains.”
Charles Hutch Press
"This was something else: imaginative, authentic, and deeply moving...the finest imaginable tribute to the great man."
Opera News
"High drama...and excellent performances...An effective and compelling dramatic presentation, as well as a reminder of our hope for a world in which people's differences of belief are tolerated and respected."
Blogcritics
“What to do with an event that resists characterization? You could feel the composer’s heart and soul…The skill on hand was unequivocally impressive."
Financial Times
“That this all had a beautiful sound goes without saying; it also had a deep and beautiful spirit and effect that went beyond music. Secret Byrd mixes music, history and drama, and what emerges is an experience that is neither concert nor theatre, but something out of life itself."
Washington Classical Review
"An intriguing example of how to create a non-traditional concert experience... It enhances the context around the music instead of competing with it. Most importantly, the theatrical presentation serves the interests of the music rather than working against it, by allowing audiences a rare chance to experience expert singers performing this detailed, intimate music in close quarters."
Opera World
"Secret Byrd is a novel and engrossing way of bringing Renaissance music to the public and is done with an intimacy and imagination that embeds this music within the world."
Opera World
Few opportunities to hear [Byrd’s] music are as intimate or visceral as Bill Barclay’s “Secret Byrd,” an immersive program extremely on trend for classical music right now…The Gesualdo Six sang magnificently in tune; the ensemble was faultless. Their sound is precision-tooled for blend, perfectly rounded, and has the utmost ease and precision.
The Tablet
Secret Byrd ... is the brainchild of Bill Barclay, a well-established master of sui generis music-theatre events. This collaboration with the vocal ensemble The Gesualdo Six and viol consort Fretwork has his meticulous fingerprints all over it.
Early Music Review
If they haven’t already filmed this, they should for when the initial tour is over. In the meantime, do try to see it live
The Guardian
The spirit of clandestine celebration of a Catholic mass is at the heart of Bill Barclay’s Secret Byrd…The all-male voices ring out with intonational precision and an almost ecstatic connection to text that would have delighted Byrd.
The Guardian
Musically it’s glorious…chillingly authentic…ominous, buoyant and uplifting… What better way to open this year’s 400th anniversary celebrations.
The Observer
Effortless Perfection.